The Best Pizza Shops on Hatteras Island
If you're craving a delicious pizza slice while visiting Hatteras Island in North Carolina, then you are lucky! This barrier island off the Outer Banks coast has several fantastic pizza shops to appease your appetite. Whether you want a quick slice or an entire pie to share with friends and family, you'll find options here to satisfy your taste buds while enjoying the beaches and relaxation this area is known for.
Hatteras Island boasts a range of pizza shops. Ranging from restaurants perfect for families to upscale pizza joints, there's a bunch to choose from. Here are the top ones to visit during your trip:
Gidget's Pizza & Pasta
Gidget's Pizza & Pasta
A local favorite in Avon, Gidget's offers classic Italian meals like calzones, pasta and pizza. They also have a great wine bar. Their hand-tossed pizzas have thin, crispy crusts and topped with fresh, delicious toppings. For a distinctive coastal twist, try the Shrimp Scampi pizza topped with garlic shrimp. With its lively, family-friendly environment, it provides a superb casual dining spot.
Angelo's Pizza
Angelo's Pizza
Situated in Buxton, Angelo's has been an essential Outer Banks pizza place for more than 25 years. They provide generous, filling portions of authentic New York-style pizza crafted with their signature robust tomato topping. The Meat Lover's is a favorite among customers, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, ham, and bacon. Angelo's casual atmosphere and adjoining arcade makes for an excellent pizza shop!
Nino's Pizza
Nino's Pizza
An unpretentious pizza joint is located right in the heart of Avon on Hatteras Island. Nino's is renowned for baking some truly delicious pizza, both traditional and unique flavors. Be certain to try the Crabby Patty pizza topped with crab dip and Old Bay seasoning for a superb coastal twist.
ISOLA Pizzeria and Bar
If you're looking for an elevated pizza experience, check out ISOLA in Hatteras. This restaurant focuses on Neapolitan-style pizzas cooked in a wood-burning oven with premium imported Italian ingredients. Their crusts - charred on the outside, soft and chewy within - make an excellent platform for fresh, inventive toppings such as prosciutto, figs, and a light brush of truffle oil. It's a classy yet casual pizza experience.
Leonardo’s Pizza
Leonardo’s Pizza
This family-run pizzeria in Waves keeps things classic with hand-tossed pizza by the slice or whole pie. Leonardo's offers quick service in a kid-friendly environment at reasonable prices. It's a solid choice for a casual pizza dinner or lunch stop while exploring all that Hatteras Island has to offer.
Dough Shack
The Dough Shack in Waves is another great spot for pizza, and the best part is you can grab some donuts while you're there! It's a small shop with very little indoor seating, but there's also some outdoor benches to look out over the sound while you eat.
Lisa's Pizzaria
Lisa's Pizzaria in Waves is another easy spot to grab a slice for lunch or dinner.
Conclusion: Your Pizza Paradise Awaits
Hatteras Island is renowned for its breathtaking landscapes and opportunities for outdoor fun. However, its collection of pizza scenes should not be overlooked. From Gidget's Italian dishes to ISOLA's innovative cuisine, any pizza lover is sure to find a slice of heaven. Whether seeking tradition or classic, this island offers pizzas to please every palette. As you plan your next trip to Hatteras Island, remember that these pizza shops offer more than just a meal—they provide a taste of island life, one delicious slice at a time.